Meeting documents
Cabinet
Wednesday, 4th December, 2002
Report to Management Board
Date |
17 November 2002 |
Reporting Area |
Transport |
Lead Director |
Clive Thomas |
SCOPE OF REPORTING AREA: Transportation is covered with Transportation, Access and Waste Management by the Access Group and the Network Group. These two groups cover the following areas:
Access Group |
Network Group |
· Transportation Planning |
· Highway Maintenance |
· Public Transport |
· Highway Development |
· Parking |
· Projects & Inventories |
· Traffic & Safety |
· Public Rights of Way |
· Road Safety |
|
· School Crossings |
Commercial Services is responsible for providing Vehicle Management and Passenger Transport services for the Council
Vehicle Management |
Passenger Services |
· Procurement, maintenance and disposal of Council `s vehicle fleet and vehicle hire · Driver assessment and training · 24 hr vehicle breakdown and recovery service · fuel purchase · accident management · contracted vehicle inspection |
· Manages the provision of a Council passenger transport service primarily from Home to School and Social Services clients · Provision of In house passenger service · Members mail and school mail services · Delivery of school meals and community meals · Transport for school swimming, games and day trips · Furniture Removal Service |
1. PROGRESS/ISSUE REPORTING
Progress Made |
Issues to be addressed |
Status/Who ? |
|
Leadership |
· 20 year Transport Vision Developed as basis for consultation · Appointments have been made to all Team Leader posts · Parish Liaison Officers identified within TAWM · Quality Bus Partnership agreed with First Group · Sub Regional drive to deal with cross authority transport issues · Proposal to pursue Quality Contract for Open Top Bus operations · Decriminalised Parking Enforcement - Joint TAWM/CS Project Team established to facilitate implementation in February 2003. |
· Wide engagement of public in major issue is continually being undertaken · Specific Advertising opportunities being pursued in Germany and Eastern Europe · Allocated Officers now working with Parishes · Two sets of detailed discussions on programme with view to documentation by December · Re-focussing remit and composition of Joint Technical Unit and committee · Financial Implications to be considered in Budget process · Managing Public Awareness through communication |
Steve Howell Human Resources Steve Howell Steve Howell |
People Management |
· The service is nearing a full compliment of staff though a significant number are agency · Decriminalisation Parking - recruitment campaign ongoing to attract an additional 30 staff required. |
· Recruitment to professional positions remains an industry wide problem. Strategic Partnership is now considered the most likely means of addressing this issue · Staff consultations ongoing regarding transfers and new centralised location. |
Steve Howell |
Policy and Strategy |
· A TAWM Improvement plan is in place which aims to improve standards within the service · Annual Submission to GOSW on Transport Plan completed · Of the 8 target Commercial Services were required to action in the first 12 months of the Best Value Action Plan all have been completed. |
· Project Manager in post to drive forward and monitor delivery of implements · A Transportation Business Plan has been prepared with resource requirements to meet improvement plan. · Response awaited in December 2002 |
Steve Howell Steve Howell |
Resources |
· Staff resources have improved and the re-organised structure is almost complete · Significant additional resources need to be committed to Transportation over a sustained period to tackle underlying poor road condition and raised quality and availability of Public Transport · Significant additional resources secured through Urban Bus Challenge to commence RUH Bus Service |
· Particular difficulty in Transport Planning - see comment above regarding Partner Procurement · The draft Business Plan addresses these issues · The inability to invest at the appropriate time and level will cause ongoing failure to address Transportation issues · Working with Bus Companies and RUH to implement |
Steve Howell/Human Resources/ Executive Council |
Process |
· The computerised information system (SBS) now extended to the help line · Palm tops being used to fully implement SBS · Systems being developed to provide KPI and management information · Individual Internal Audit reviews of Vehicle Management and Passengers completed in the last quarter. |
· Staff training being planned to ensure full use of system. · Further work needed to maximise management information over the next three months · Computerised traffic accident database continues to be refined and improved. |
Steve Howell |
2. RESULTS AGAINST TARGETS
Reporting on commitments made in the Council Strategy and Performance Plan.
Summary of Performance
Performance Targets |
No. |
% |
RED |
3 |
11 |
AMBER |
1 |
4 |
GREEN |
17 |
63 |
NOT KNOWN |
6 |
22 |
3. Key Performance Indicators
Ref. |
Indicator |
2001/02 Actual |
2002/03 Estimate |
2002/03 Target |
2003/03 Latest Estimate |
Status |
Comment |
Best Value Performance Indicators |
|||||||
96 |
Percentage of the principal roads network with negative residual life |
23% |
20% |
20% |
RED |
Works programme does not address maintenance backlog on PRN |
|
97a |
Percentage of the non-principal roads network with negative residual life |
39% |
35% |
35% |
NK |
Detailed survey of whole non principal network being undertaken |
|
97b |
Percentage of the non-principal roads network with negative residual life |
42% |
38% |
38% |
NK |
||
99a |
Number of road accidents casualties per 100,000 population - killed/seriously injured |
36 |
N/A |
40 |
? |
NK |
Relate to previous calendar year |
99b |
Number of road accidents casualties per 100,000 population - slightly injured |
301 |
N/A |
258 |
? |
NK |
Relate to previous calendar year |
100 |
Number of days of temporary traffic controls or road closure on traffic sensitive roads caused by road works per kilometre of traffic sensitive roads |
NEW |
4.2 |
Green |
Now include utilities' work |
||
102 |
Local bus services (million passenger journeys per year) |
6.73 |
6.8 |
6.8 |
6.8 |
Green |
Major change in figures due to audit of data in bus quality partnership |
165 |
Percentage of pedestrian crossings with facilities for disabled people |
92% |
96% |
96% |
Amber |
Dependant on UTMC development |
|
178 |
The percentage of total length of footpaths and other rights of way which were easy to use by members of the public |
80% |
77% |
Nk |
2001/2 figure distorted by foot & mouth |
||
186a |
The percentage of principal roads not needing major repair |
NEW |
80% |
80% |
Green |
Works progressing to programme |
|
186b |
The percentage of non-principal roads not needing major repair |
NEW |
63% |
63% |
Green |
Works progressing to programme |
|
187 |
Condition of footways |
NEW |
Unlikely to be collated this year |
RED |
Highway management software not yet developed |
||
94X |
Cost per passenger kilometre of subsidised bus services |
£1.55 |
£1.50 |
£1.50 |
£1.50 |
Nk |
Deleted as BVPI will be retained as local indicator |
105X |
Number of all reported incidents of dangerous damage to roads and pavements repaired or made safe within 24 hours from the time that the authority first |
100% |
100% |
100% |
100% |
Green |
Deleted as BVPI will be retained as local indicator |
93X |
Cost of highway maintenance per 100 kilometres travelled by a vehicle on principal roads |
£0.21 |
To be deleted as BVPI - will not be retained as local indicator |
||||
95x |
Average cost of a working streetlight |
Data not yet available |
To be deleted as BVPI - will not be retained as local indicator |
||||
Performance Plan Commitments |
|||||||
P17 |
Devevelop a bus quality partnership |
Do It |
Green |
Dept on exec approval |
|||
P17 |
Feasibility study of demand responsive transport provision |
Do It |
Green |
Study complete now avanced to bid for funds via Bus Urban Challenge post study |
|||
P17 |
Introduce decriminalised parking throughout B&NES |
Do It |
Green |
Progressing to programme |
|||
P20 |
Implement the Street Lighting Policy and Strategy, ensuring the safety of the community whilst seeking to minimise light pollution |
Do It |
Green |
3 of 7 elements active remainder to be adopted as developed |
|||
P22 |
Apply for secure car park status for additional sites |
Do It |
Green |
||||
Service Plan Commitments |
|||||||
SP 4 |
Development of partnership approach to Highway term maintenance contract |
Do It |
Green |
||||
SP 4 |
Develop systems to control and plan activity on the highway through SBS system |
Do It |
Green |
UKPMS compliant system to be installed by December - Data capture complete |
|||
SP7 |
Develop management systems to track operational and financial performance |
Do It |
Green |
||||
SP12 |
Increase responsiveness to reports of safety defects and develop monitoring system |
Do It |
Green |
System monitoring in place and response less than 24hours |
|||
SP12 |
Develop highway development design guide |
Do It |
RED |
Team resources do not permit this to be developed |
|||
SP12 |
Develop capital budget monitoring system |
Do It |
Green |
Initial system being tested |
|||
SP13 |
Develop greater levels of contract supervision and control of subsidised bus contracts |
Do It |
Green |
Enhanced supervision in place |
|||
SP16 |
Introduce Ice Alert system for highway winter maintenance |
Do It |
Green |
Planned to be operational by December |
Recruitment and Retention Equalities & DDA Targets |
|||||
02/03 Actual |
03/04 target |
04/05 target |
05/06 target |
07/08 target |
|
Percentage of employees meeting DDA definition |
1.3% |
2% |
2% |
2.6% |
2.6% |
Percentage of employees within ethnic minority categories |
0.6% |
0.6% |
1.3% |
1.3% |
2% |
The service currently employs 157 staff of whom approximately 1/3 are school crossing patrols. Recruitment of SCPs is proving extremely difficult and historically there have been very few application from individuals in either of the two categories. The role of SCP requires good vision and hearing as well as reasonable mobility that precludes the employment of individuals meeting DDA definitions
Supplementary Transportation Indicators
Highway Maintenance
Maintenance Backlog Principal Roads
23% of the 122km of principal road network has no residual life.
The following figures are based on a 33year carriageway operational life and a cost of £400k per km for major structural maintenance.
In order to maintain a steady state 122/33 x £4005,000 = £1,480,000 should be spent on PRN structural maintenance annually - Historically this figure has not been met for several years.
The TAWM business plan identifies two levels of spend which will achieve recovery in highway condition in 5 and 11 years
1999/00 |
2000/01 |
2001/02 |
2002/03 |
2003/04 |
2004/05 |
2005/06 |
2006/07 |
2007/08 |
2008/09 |
2009/10 |
2010/11 |
2011/12 |
2012/13 |
||
Capital spend on PRN maintenance - historic |
200 |
450 |
650 |
780 |
|||||||||||
Planned spend - 11 year recovery (by 12/13) |
1600 |
2400 |
2400 |
2800 |
2800 |
2800 |
2800 |
2900 |
2900 |
2900 |
|||||
Projected % with <0 residual life 11 Year plan |
23% |
23% |
23% |
24% |
24% |
22% |
20% |
18% |
15% |
13% |
10% |
7% |
4% |
1% |
|
Planned spend - 5 year recovery (by 06/07) |
3300 |
3900 |
3900 |
3900 |
|||||||||||
Projected % with <0 residual life 5 year plan |
23% |
23% |
23% |
23% |
19% |
15% |
10% |
5% |
0% |
Highway Revenue Budget Maintenance Spend
1997/98 |
1998/99 |
1999/00 |
2000/01 |
2001/02 |
2002/03(to October) |
|
Reactive |
1,702,857 |
1,657,079 |
1,252,421 |
1,844,004 |
2,164,851 |
598,053 |
Planned |
620,541 |
774,750 |
1,018,451 |
769,883 |
420,871 |
32,719 |
Overall |
2,323,398 |
2,431,829 |
2,270,872 |
2,613,887 |
2,585,722 |
630,772 |
Planned/Reactive Ratio |
0.36 |
0.47 |
0.81 |
0.42 |
0.19 |
0.05 |
Transport Indicators
Average age of Public Transport Bus Fleet |
9.58 years |
|||
Total road length of bus priority measures |
1.11km |
|||
Total length of Cycle Network |
62.1km |
|||
Taxis with facilities for disabled |
||||
Bath |
6No |
7% |
||
Other areas |
6No |
19% |
||
Park & ride patronage (cumulative usage in financial year) |
669285 No |
2% |
||
Rail patronage (day survey data) |
11521 |
13.4% |
||
Education Transport - Daily passengers |
Sub Contracted Routes |
2218 |
Total =2729 daily trips |
|
Passenger Fleet Routes |
71 |
|||
Public Service Routes |
440 |
On Street Parking |
August 2002 |
September 2002 |
October 2002 |
|||||||||||||||||||||
Total ticket salesCentral Parking Zone |
30 min |
60 min |
120 min |
total |
30 min |
60 min |
120 min |
total |
30 min |
60 min |
120 min |
total |
||||||||||||
11809 |
19385 |
7469 |
38843 |
12296 |
18951 |
7217 |
38464 |
12747 |
20566 |
8119 |
41432 |
|||||||||||||
Total Ticket SalesZone 1 |
<30 min |
40-60 min |
70-90 min |
100-120 min |
Total |
<30 min |
40-60 min |
70-90 min |
100-120 min |
Total |
<30 min |
40-60 min |
70-90 min |
100-120 min |
Total |
|||||||||
3202 |
5848 |
1697 |
14932 |
25679 |
3210 |
5881 |
1862 |
13809 |
24762 |
3091 |
5985 |
1980 |
14835 |
25891 |
OFFICIAL COMPLAINTS MONITORING
Ref |
Nature of Complaint |
Date Received |
Date Resolved |
Comment/Subsequent change to procedures? |
OC20 |
Lack of footway in Stockwood Vale, promise of works not done. Drainage problems, lack of sweeping. |
12th April 2002 |
23rd April 2002 |
Complaint acknowledged. Advised that delay in work undertaken was due to lack of resources (staff wise) but that work was programmed and would take place ASAP. Maintenance issues, patching due to be done by end of April. Acknowledged there are drainage problems. Scheme is on rolling programme to improve. Will be considered on priority list basis when funding permits. Area will be inspected and cleansing needed will be put on programme as necessary. |
OC21 |
Lack of dropped kerb on pedestrian footway at either side of pedestrian refuge at junct. of Bathwick St and Henrietta Road |
19th April 2002 |
20th May 2002 |
Complaint upheld. Dropped kerbs are to be reinstated. These were omitted when original works were undertaken. Clerk of works has been requested to have reinstatement done ASAP. |
OC22 |
Complaint re trip on raised manhole in Ashgrove, PSJ |
8th May 2002 |
31st May 2002 |
Complaint upheld. Cover belonged to Bristol Water. Section 81 notice served and repairs were undertaken. Remainder of road will be monitored on safety checks and repairs undertaken as necessary. |
OC23 |
Complaint re lack of highway drainage causing floods to property |
24th May 2002 |
Still ongoing further investigations necessary. Complainant not satisfied. Complaint upheld. Will be moving gully further up the road and will be lowering a second gully to catch water flow and alleviate flooding. |
|
OC24 |
Complaint about pedestrian crossing in High Street and standard of maintenance |
25th June 2002 |
4th July 2002 |
Complaint not upheld. Crossing installation decision taken after vehicle and pedestrian traffic counts and consideration of the amount of traffic in the area. Location has not been decided, this will be considered and the proposal advertised in the usual way. Maintenance inspections are up to date and any necessary works have been dealt with or put on the relevant programme of works. Unable to comment on various officers named as no specific situation advised in the letter. 30th July 2002, Mr H phoned Steve Howell. He was asked to write in with areas of specific concern so that they can be responded to in full. NOW GONE TO STAGE 2 OFFICER DAMIAN WILSON. SED. 5.11.02 |
OC25 |
Complaint that bus stops have not been replaced in Redfield Road and the amount of overgrown vegetation in Church Lane |
15th July 2002 |
26th July 2002 |
Complaint upheld. Bus stop sign has been reinstated and an order has been issued to contractor re vegetation on Church Lane. Notices to be sent to the landowners of North Road to have their overgrown vegetation cut back. |
OC26 |
Complaint regarding Green Street in Bath. When the carriageway was raised to same level as footway, (for busgate) has now caused vehicles to overrun the footway when vehicles are parked at the side of the road. Wants something done to stop this practice. |
31st July 2002 by phone Barbara Selby |
28th August 2002 |
Complaint upheld. Bollards had been originally included in the design of the scheme for the area but were omitted after consultation due to practicality issues as the street was not wide enough. Solutions are currently being sought to resolve the situation in Green Street, which will probably include bollards of some sort. |
OC27 |
Complaint re St Catherines Parish Council have sought a traff reg order on Stony Lane since 1995. Feels that the council have failed to address the TRO in a reasonable timescale or take appropriate steps to minimise a traffic hazard. |
12th August 2002 (Will Steel) |
2nd September 2002 |
Complaint not upheld Mr S advised that progress could not be made until the suitable policy framework was in place to manage such a traffic order. It is hoped that this will be available within 6 months. |