Decision details
Bath City Centre Security
Decision Maker: Cabinet
Decision status: Approved
Is Key decision?: Yes
Is subject to call in?: Yes
Purpose:
Decision on (Anti-Terrorism) Traffic
Regulation Orders for Bath City Centre Security scheme which
includes for access restrictions to York Street, Cheap Street/
Westgate Street, Upper Borough Walls, Lower Borough Walls and Hot
Bath Street, Bath
Decision:
RESOLVED (unanimously) that the Cabinet agreed to:
1.To approve the TRO (for anti-terrorism purposes) for advertisement such that it would operate between 1000 hours and 1800 hours on the following streets:
(1) Lower Borough Walls, Stall Street, including Abbeygate Street, Abbey Green, Swallow Street (South), Bath Street and Hot Bath Street
(2) York Street
2. To approve the TRO (for anti-terrorism purposes) for advertisement such that it would operate between 1000 hours and 1800 hours on the following streets:
(1) Cheap Street, Westgate Street, Saw Close and Upper Borough Walls
with access to the restricted streets also being provided to Blue Badge Holders, carers transporting Blue Badge Holders, and taxi’s transporting Blue Badge Holders. Access would be provided via Controlled Authorised Access by the Council’s CCTV team.
3. To advertise the TRO between 1800 hours and 2200 hours on York Street, to reflect its proximity to the Roman Baths and to support the increased footfall from Terrace Walk through York Street to the new Clore Learning Centre and World Heritage Centre. The Roman Baths, Clore Learning Centre and World Heritage Centre will, at times, be open late into the evening.
4. To note that we will not advertise the TRO between 2200 hours and 1000 hours on York Street.
5. To note that we will not advertise the TRO between 1800 hours and 1000 hours for the following streets:
(1) Lower Borough Walls, Stall Street, including Abbeygate Street, Abbey Green, Swallow Street (South), Bath Street and Hot Bath Street
(2) Cheap Street, Westgate Street, Saw Close and Upper Borough Walls
when the streets are not deemed as crowded, based on footfall data and the
security risk is not considered to be proportionate to the terrorist threat.
ATTRO - 1000 to 1800 hours with no blue badge access |
ATTRO – 1000 to 1800 hours with blue badge access |
TRO - 1800 to 2200 hours |
No TRO 2200 to 1000 hours |
No TRO 1800 to 1000 hours |
York Street Lower Borough Walls Stall Street Abbeygate Street Abbey Green Swallow Street (south) Bath Street Hot Bath Street |
Cheap Street Westgate Street Saw Close Upper Borough Walls |
York Street |
York Street |
Lower Borough Walls Stall Street Abbeygate Street Abbey Green Swallow Street (south) Bath Street Hot Bath Street Cheap Street Westgate Street Saw Close Upper Borough Walls |
6. Delegate to the Director of Place Management in consultation with the Cabinet Member for Transport the operational management procedures for access to the restricted streets.
7. To note that subject to investigations which are currently taking place on vault survey works, to determine exact locations, based on engineering design options, a series of suitable Hostile Vehicle Mitigation (HVM) measures to be installed at the entrance/exit to the following streets within the city centre. Exact locations to be delegated to Director of Place Management in consultation with Cabinet Member for Transport, with access provided via Controlled Authorised Access by the Council’s CCTV team:
(1) York Street
(2) Cheap Street
(3) Upper Borough Walls
(4) Lower Borough Walls
(5) Hot Bath Street
8. To note that subject to investigations, enhance existing street furniture with a series of public realm HVM measures to the following streets:
(1) Old Bond St (North)
(2) Burton St (North) (incl occasional access)
(3) New Bond St Place (North)
(4) New Bond St Place (South)
(5) Northumberland Place
(6) The Corridor
(7) Barton St/ Saw Close (incl occasional access)
(8) Seven Dials (incl occasional access)
(9) Chandos Buildings (West)
(10) Hetling Court (West)
(11) Beau St (East) (incl occasional access)
(12) New Orchard St (East) (incl occasional access)
(13) Southgate St (south)
(14) Kingston Buildings (Orange Grove)
9. To note the recommended series of mitigation measures, to support the City Centre Security programme, as highlighted in the Accessibility Study, namely:
(1) Additional seating to be installed on Cheap Street and Westgate Street
(2) Dropped kerbs and footway surface improvements to allow improved
accessibility from existing city centre car parks and proposed additional blue
badge bays.
(3) Provide additional blue badge and loading bays (as detailed in 3.20 below)
(4) Clear and accessible Communications Plan
10. To note that recommended additional measures, in a phased approach, from both the Consultation Report and Accessibility Study will be considered as part of wider Bath City Centre public realm and transport improvement programmes, with an holistic approach, working with Accessibility Groups, businesses and residents. This request is subject to approval of the revenue and capital budget provisions by Cabinet and Council as part of the council’s budget setting process.
11. Advertise TRO’s as necessary for all the restricted streets to prevent all waiting, except for the provision of parking for Blue Badge Holders and loading/ unloading for specific time periods
12. Enable the TRO (for anti-terrorism purposes) restrictions to prevent access by Blue Badge Holders, and identified delivery vehicles, should the National or local security risk increase to severe or critical, and as advised by the Police, either for an unplanned incident or planned event, ie Bath Christmas Market/Remembrance Services, as per the Operational Management Procedures.
13. To note the resource implications set out in section 5 of the report, final scheme design and financial implications will require the approval of the Chief Financial Officer and Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Resources and Economic Development.
Reasons for the decision:
Since 2016 the Council and South West Counter Terrorism Advisors (CTSA’s),
with Avon & Somerset Police, have worked together on preventative measures
to reduce the risk of a terrorist attack in the City. These include temporary
hostile vehicle mitigations (HVM) for events, such as the Christmas Market and
Remembrance Services and specific training for CCTV operatives, front-line
staff, managers, and senior officers across private, public and third sector
organisations, including regular deployments of Avon & Somerset Police’s
Project Servator teams.
The Council with CTSA’s have focussed attention on areas identified as crowded places, with the Chief Constable of Avon & Somerset Police writing to the Council on 21 February 2020 (Attached at Appendix 2) to recommend the
Council introduce an Anti-Terrorism Traffic Regulation Order (“ATTRO”) in
respect of all roads within the area defined within the map attached as Appendix
3.
The Council is now required to make a decision on a proportionate response to
the Chief Constable’s letter, which also takes into account the Council’s duties
under the Equality Act 2010 and public consultation carried out from November
2020 to January 2021, with consideration to the Accessibility Study and
subsequent recommendations
Alternative options considered:
As per report.
Report author: Lynda Deane
Publication date: 20/07/2021
Date of decision: 20/07/2021
Decided at meeting: 20/07/2021 - Cabinet
Effective from: 28/07/2021
Accompanying Documents:
- Decision E3278 PDF 108 KB
- E3278 City Centre Security Cabinet Report FINAL PDF 457 KB
- Restricted enclosure View reasons restricted
- Appendix 1 - Exemption LGA Ref 839 21 PDF 125 KB
- Appendix 2 - Letter from CC Marsh to Bath and North East Somerset Council - 21.02.2020 PDF 309 KB
- Appendix 3 - Proposed Bath City Centre Security Map PDF 763 KB
- Appendix 4 - Letter from CC Marsh to Mr Godfrey RE Bath ATTRO 25.05.2021 PDF 199 KB
- Appendix 5 - Proposed HVM for Protective Measures PDF 399 KB
- Appendix 6 - City Centre ATTRO Legal Advice PDF 597 KB
- Appendix 7a - Risk Assessment - City Centre Security MTFA June 2021 - Final PDF 325 KB
- Appendix 7b - Risk Assessment City Centre Security IED June 2021 - Final PDF 395 KB
- Appendix 7c - HVM Risk Assessment Cheap St PDF 282 KB
- Appendix 7d - HVM Risk Assessment Lwr Borough Walls PDF 282 KB
- Appendix 7e - HVM Risk Assessment York St PDF 282 KB
- Appendix 7f - Impact Assessment - Residents PDF 278 KB
- Appendix 7g - Impact Assessment Business & Deliveries PDF 278 KB
- Appendix 7h - Impact Assessment Disabled PDF 278 KB
- Appendix 8 - Equalities Impact Assessment - City Centre Security - Final 29 June 2021 PDF 271 KB
- Appendix 9 - Bath_City_Centre_Accesibility_Study_Final_Issued PDF 877 KB
- Appendix 10 - City Centre Consultation Feedback Report 18.5.21 PDF 3 MB
- Appendix 11 - Feedback on consultation reports 210602 PDF 128 KB